Reviews

The Music of Unexpected Things by Jamie Deacon

nattie19's review

Go to review page

emotional hopeful lighthearted relaxing medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

catsandcamera's review

Go to review page

4.0

The Music of Unexpected Things takes place over a few weeks, where our characters are at an invite only summer school at a prestigious music academy. Over the weeks they're there to show their musical talent and eventually one will get a scholarship to return to the school after the holidays. But really, that's the backdrop. This book is very much about the characters and their relationships - platonic and romantic - with the musical aspect bringing them together.

The book is told from two perspectives, Georgie and Mina. Georgie is very much an introvert, she's shy and reserved because of past experiences as a blind girl with a guide dog. Peers and adults alike have treated her as a burden rather than a person. On the other side we have Mina, who is a lot more open and confident, but due to her religious upbringing, she's scared to be open about her feelings - as someone who wants to pursue music as a proper career, and as a girl who likes girls.

Both characters are great, and both have distinct voices. I never once got confused as to who's perspective I was in, and I enjoyed seeing the thoughts and feelings of each character, and how their pasts, family and friendships had shaped them up to this point. The wider cast were great too, with their own personalities and storylines going on. Gareth, Zephan and Art again, were all distinct and had their own things going on, away from the two main protagonists. Although he got the least page time and least background, I was very fond of Zephan, the moody cynic who spends his time reading and scoffing at the others drama, whilst also being a great friend and knowing when to talk or listen to the others.

One thing I do think should have been addressed though, in some sort of way, was the fact that guide dogs are working. They're doing a job, and shouldn't be distracted from that. Several times throughout the book - basically any time anyone met Georgie and Star (her dog) - they initially went to Star and started petting her and giving her attention. I can totally understand why Georgie as the shy, socially awkward person she is didn't say anything out loud, but I would have loved to see either an inner thought recognising that this isn't the thing to do to working dogs. Or at least some sort of conversation at a later date with a friend after they had got to know each other. I just thought that conversation was lacking in here. Even a simple throw away line while taking with friends like 'yeah, everyone who meets us fusses Star, but no one really realises that she's not a pet, she's working as an extension of me' and the friend to be like 'damn, yeah I didn't think of that, sorry if that's the way I approached you when we met'.

The romantic relationships in here were everything you'd expect from a YA book, both sweet and dramatic, pretty and petty. There were ups and downs but they felt pretty realistic.

All in all I very much enjoyed this book

ARC copy.

dianebillas's review

Go to review page

adventurous hopeful medium-paced

5.0

 The Music of Unexpected Things is a page-turner about music, resilience, and first love. Set in a dual perspective at a summer music camp, readers are bound to root for Georgie and Mina. 

akacya's review

Go to review page

3.5

2024 reads: 271/250

i received an advanced review copy from the author in exchange for an honest review. this did not affect my rating.

it’s every young musician’s dream to attend dukes academy. each july, gifted teens from across the country attend the academy’s four-week summer camp, at the end of which one will receive a scholarship to attend the school full-time. georgie’s excited for camp, but for her, it’s more than just music: it’s an opportunity to make friends. mina’s main concern is about the scholarship, as she feels it’s the only way to get her traditional parents to allow her to study anything besides medicine. as the two become friends, they begin to develop romantic feelings for each other.

i loved that we got both georgie’s and mina’s perspectives because they were so unique while also having some of the same goals in mind. georgie has been treated with pity in the past due to being “the blind girl,” so she’s having trouble trusting that her new friends are being genuine. mina has to hide a lot from her parents, so she’s having trouble opening up to her new friends. these two really brought out the best in each other!

one thing i didn’t love about this book was how fast-paced the relationships were. compared to a side couple, georgie and mina’s romance was a bit of a slow-burn, but still, the book takes place over four weeks. i know that some high school relationships can be this way, though, so it’s not something i’m judging too harshly.

overall, this was a lovely book. i’d recommend it to anyone wanting a summery romance read.

eshurricane's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous emotional funny hopeful inspiring reflective sad tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

I absolutely adored this book! It's a love letter to music, young love, and the turmoil of being a teenager discovering themselves. The main characters all have diverse backgrounds in their families and struggle in different ways, having to overcome so much in just one summer.

This is the kind of YA that doesn't shy away from the tough stuff but does it in a safe environment, with the characters coming through the other side understanding what's right and what they should focus on. I was also impressed with how big of a role the parents of some of the characters played despite them not being physically present at the music school. Their development over the course of the book was also important and I love that it was shown.

The writing was gorgeous with great descriptions, especially with one of the protagonists being blind, it was interesting to read her perception of the world. There's a lot of focus on taste and smell and auditory senses, whereas the other protagonist focuses more on what she can see. This type of diversity in the character POVs felt really authentic and made for very clear character voices in the different chapters.

All in all, very enjoyable and sweet read! I am a sucker for a good sapphic romance no matter the ages of the characters, but I was really impressed with how poignant this was. This is the kind of YA that I would give to my kids to read when they're teenagers. 10/10!

mollyringle's review

Go to review page

emotional funny inspiring lighthearted medium-paced
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes

5.0

I’ve been a fan of Jamie Deacon’s writing ever since discovering their work many years ago, and I’m charmed with this new book! Even though I rarely read YA these days, I was pleased to find this is the type of YA anyone (in my opinion) can appreciate: it doesn’t feel dumbed down; rather, it insightfully captures the feeling of what it’s like to be a teen, independent in ways, yet insecure in other ways and still tied to the expectations of your family. 
 
It's also got great representation on many angles—queerness, disability, mental health, and more. Georgie, one of the two main protagonists, provides the perspective of a blind character (with an awesome guide dog)—which is also an Own Voices angle, as Deacon mentions in the afterword that they themself are registered blind. Georgie’s passion for music has brought her to a summer session at Dukes, an acclaimed British music school, where she and all the other attending teens are crossing their fingers for a coveted scholarship. But what she ends up wanting even more, within a couple of weeks there, is Mina, a sweet fellow student with whom she strikes up a friendship. Soon it’s clear they both desire more. Can they let it blossom into a proper romance, or will their anxiety over their family’s attitudes, and their own insecurities, keep them apart? 
 
The story felt natural, with a wonderfully diverse cast of side friends who I loved just as much as our central couple, and I especially delighted in the banter, which often made me grin. The setting itself is alluring too: if you have even the smallest music-loving bone in your body, you’ll fall in love with Dukes and wish it were real so you could spend a season there yourself, no matter your age. Excellent read for anyone desiring a musical, sapphic, disability-affirming story!