An interesting continuation to the first book of the series. However, it does leave you where you NEED to read the next book to find out what happens next, which is somewhat annoying. I’d say it’s a good story, but definitely not my favorite Warriors book. The

tribe plot line

seemed a little random to have. I hope it appears in the future because if not it seems kind of useless and only exists to

kill off Feathertail

but I do have to admit that

her death

had caught me off guard. I always thought it would be Stormfur. This book also seems to focus a lot on

Romance

which, I’m not complaining, I was just surprised. I also found that the

Hawkfrost twist

was a little repetitive. It’s already been done, what, two times now? I wish they had focused on the

two leg issue

more than try to add more problems. It feels like they were trying to write two different books at once. Despite all my criticism, it was a pretty decent book. I enjoyed the story and it had me hooked from the beginning. I was just hoping for something more original, though. 

I really liked this one! I actually really like The New Prophecy cast and as I said in my review of Midnight, it used to be my least favourite as a kid. I'm not sure if I'll agree by the end of this journey, but so far it's been fun.

Feathertail's death is the first death that has gotten me close to crying,

and I barely cry reading books!!

Something about that callback to Crowpaw about not having to save him again??? OUCH.

I also like the Tribe of Rushing Water a lot because they're so desperate that it tains their actions and it's super interesting to me. Brook is the absolute babygirl though, I love her. She genuinely meant well from the start you can't blame her, she just wanted the best for everyone involved.